Stock Market Highs, Risks, and Uncertainty: Navigating Market Volatility
Stock Market Highs, Risks, and Uncertainty: Navigating Market Volatility
In this episode of Something More with Chris Boyd, Chris is joined by Jeff Perry and Russ Paul from the AMR team to tackle the big questions surrounding today’s markets. With stocks hitting new highs, excitement is in the air, but so is risk. We explore what could shake investor confidence, from prolonged government shutdowns and missing economic data to geopolitical tensions and Supreme Court decisions. Plus, we share practical strategies for both retirees and accumulators: when to rebalance, how to manage liquidity, and why time in the market beats timing the market. If uncertainty makes you nervous, this conversation will help you keep perspective and stick to your financial plan.
#FinancialPlanning #MarketRisk #InvestingWisely #StockMarket #RetirementPlanning
#DollarCostAveraging #AMRTeam #SomethingMorePodcast #EconomicUncertainty
#WealthManagement #PortfolioStrategy #WealthManagement #ChrisBoyd #JeffPerry
#RussBall #FinanicialPlanning #Inthenews #Governmentshutdown
0:00 Welcome to Something More with Chris Boyd. Chris Boyd is a Certified Financial Planner Practitioner and Senior Vice President and Financial Advisor at Wealth Enhancement Group, one of the nation's largest registered investment advisors. We call it Something More because we'd like to talk not only about those important dollar and cents issues, but also the quality of life issues that make the money matters matter. Here he is, your fulfillment facilitator, your partner in prosperity, advising clients on Cape Cod and across the country. Here's your host, Jay Christopher Boyd. All right, welcome. Thanks for being with us. I'm Chris Boyd. I'm here with Jeff Ferry and Russ Paul. We are all of the AMR team.
0:41 Glad to have you with us for another episode of Something More. And today we're talking about markets and market risk. You know, as we continually bump up to new highs, people get very excited about stocks. It's good to have exposure to the growth in wealth that comes with equities, but there often is volatility and can be a risk. And so people are worried about when's the other shoe going to drop? What's going to cause markets to have a problem? And so, yeah, I think it's important for us to keep perspective.
1:25 So we'll talk about some of these risks, but let's remember, one, most people don't have only stock. They have other investments too. Hopefully you have some reserves, so it's not every day of your investments in your portfolio percent to have some liquidity. And, you know, recognize that volatility is part of the process. We get benefit from participation over time. And what drives markets ultimately is the combination of things when it comes back to profitability.
2:05 Are companies, broadly speaking, going to be more profitable or less profitable as we look into the future? And if we expect they're going to have increased profitability, we might expect to see performance of stocks grow, the market to grow. If we think that things are going to be disrupted for a while over time, that may change the way we think about the performance of stocks. I'm sure there's more that we can dig into, but let's start off, Jeff, a little bit about what we want to hit on, the risks that might be out there today that people might be focused on.
2:47 Well, unfortunately, I think people are too focused on the risks by watching too much television, because, you know, you can watch the financial channels or the cable news channels, and it seems to be this unending risk news, right? So we have the risk of the government shutdown. I guess we just alert, right? At the breaking news, right? The music sounds, you know, like, oh, what's happening, you know? Do you remember the day when breaking news was actually something everybody ran to actually happen? You ran to the living room to say, what's going on in the world? A major world event is happening. And now it's just kind of what we're talking about today.
3:32 Breaking news is not always breaking news. No, it isn't. But something that it's not breaking, it's actually 37 days old. One of the risks that people are starting to calculate or attempt to measure, is it a risk to the stock market and investments is the government shutdown. We're in day 37 here and counting. There doesn't seem to be, you know, light at the end of the tunnel, at least not at the moment. And, you know, at first glance for the short shutdown, I think if you're a government employee, this is a whole different conversation, right? If you're a federal employee, you got to have that caveat, you're right.
4:13 If you're someone whose job is disrupted, your cash, your paychecks are not coming in. It's a very different story than kind of everybody else who's not a government employee. Yeah, I don't want to come across as not being sympathetic to our federal employees and contractors and all the people that are related to this. But just from a broader perspective about risks to your portfolio, risk to the market, risk to the economy. I think when it started, the government shutdown, people assumed a week or two, de minimis, you know, not a big deal. We know that a lot of money that people get paid on isn't in the economy.
4:55 But one paycheck that'll catch up, they get retroactive. But now, I don't know, Chris and Russ, if you see this differently, this is starting to mean something to the broader economy and could even mean more the longer it goes on. Russ, do you want to comment? Yeah, I mean, it's definitely longer than we probably thought when this all started and longer than a lot of people thought. Usually these government shutdowns are a couple weeks and then it's wrapped up, there's some kind of agreement, and at least things are kicked down the road a little bit. Not so much this time. I know President Trump was making some comments the other day after some of the wins for the Democratic Party in the elections.
5:43 Was that yesterday or the day before? I can't remember. A couple days ago, yeah. But he was referencing the fact that he thought the government shutdown did have a negative impact on the Republican turnout. And it was sort of like, all right, I wonder what's going to happen out of this. Is this going to be more digging your heels in or looking to go to the negotiating table? So it remains to be seen, but the longer this goes, the more the market's going to get jittery, I would imagine, and start wondering, something's got to give here. The uncertainty of it all, I mean, it's uncertain because we don't know the end, but it's also uncertain on things that we rely on to gauge how the economy's doing.
6:28 The federal government is the primary source of data, unemployment data, CPI data, so forth, all these things that the Bureau of Labor Statistics and individual regulatory agencies of the federal government report out as a normal course of business kind of guide people who are looking at the market and gauging whether or not the economy's strong, are we in a recession, is the Federal Reserve more likely to lower interest rates because of unemployment issues, et cetera. And so it's been a month and we don't have any of that data, so that leads to uncertainty and the market doesn't prefer uncertainty.
7:10 And I know Fed Chair Powell is talking about, right now it's like we're driving a car down a foggy street, and there's not a lot of information. And he's definitely urging caution in terms of what the next Fed move is going to be. But that's a good analogy as to where things stand right now. It's hard to know when you don't have the barometers that you're used to. And there are some real points, too. What happens when you have that foggy environment? Things start to slow, right? You get more costs, and that happens in business as well. Either that or you drive off the road.
7:50 Right? And it has some, not just uncertainty, but it has some real practical negative impacts on the economy. You think about companies or organizations that have to go for regulatory approval to do something, whether it's to permit something or to whatever it is. So much of these processes go through the federal government at some point, and that's just not functioning either. And so there's a backup building there. It's going to lead to a slowdown in those projects, which leads to a slowdown in hiring, et cetera. So I think the initial thought rests, I agree with you, a couple weeks.
8:32 Now we're into day 37 and counting. And the longer it goes, the greater the financial economic impact it has to people and the uncertainty for the employees. And there's greater demands for help and assistance from people, for people like, and that throws off paying and spending, and there's a slowing effect in everyone as well. Yeah. One of our clients is one of the managers of a food bank down here. And through the Catholic Church, the church has their own food bank, but it's a very robust one serving more than the church, more than the parishioners.
9:18 And he, I saw him the other day and he's just like, they are out straight with having to limit what people take because they can't feed the whole community and the church is putting in extra money and it's just, it's impacting that part of the economy as well. So, you know, they just, yep. And the, you know, it's a larger political question, but the 40 million people on SNAP benefits did not receive their benefit. And that money filtered its way into the economy. I mean, they spend it on perishables and, you know, food items primarily, and those purchases are not being made.
9:59 And so does that affect certain industries? Of course it does. So that's one of the, one of the, you know, kind of right now risks to the market. That's, that's a tangible, I think that example, when you read it in terms of how this has some ripple effect, where I think a lot of these are things that we kind of don't see so much, but it's still there having an effect where it's not as, it's not as in front of us in the news as much. Yeah. Another market risk that I've been thinking about a lot is not directly related to the government shutdown, but tangentially it's certainly related and longer it goes is we're starting to see some cracks in the credit and debt issues of consumers before the shutdown, where more and more student loans are being in default.
10:55 There's some cracks in the car loan numbers. You know, people are getting behind on those. I think before the government shutdown, it was probably related to, you know, pressures on inflation, such job fears. But this is all just going to magnify those credit and debt issues, I think. I agree. I mean, there's going to be a lot of people who are trying to fund their circumstances and the government shutdown with no paycheck or disrupted income with credit, this will have a prolonged consequence. Or not, or not paying credit that you already have.
11:37 Or not paying credit you already have. Yeah. They're going into default. No, your student loan is pretty far down the list when you're trying to sit down the table and keep the lights on. Right. And stay in your home. Yep. So all these negative things and kind of local things and things that might be part of the government shutdown are risks to the market. The market is, I don't know, maybe this week paying a little bit more attention to it seems to be some increased volatility. Yeah. Not the straight line. Well, we still have those things that always are risks to the market. And certainly in our news, global tensions, global issues certainly drive the market volatility positively or negatively.
12:23 So I don't know. You think we're having improvements in the global risk to the market? We had President Trump kind of make a deal with China or at least a positive meeting, he seemed to have a good meeting with South Korea and Japan. Yeah. Certainly other parts, other countries as well, whether or not we had material improvement with China remains to be determined. But at least tonally, I guess you'd say there's improvement. Yeah. With other countries, we did get some furtherance of trade negotiations.
13:04 I always forget the rarer of metals deals. It seems to be a positive. Yeah. Sure. So, you know, fingers crossed. I think broadly though, when you talk about global issues, there's always the uncertainty of tensions with countries and what will bubble up. We see some improvements, I'd say, in the Middle East, right? What's happened recently with the Gulf and so forth, seems to be moving in a more favorable direction with Palestine.
13:53 With regard to Ukraine though, that remains really not in any kind of a better trajectory as we look at that. And then there's always the unknown. Well, one of those might be the military presence off the coast of Venezuela. That's increasing over the last week or two. I think the world's largest aircraft carrier is on its way down there. Yeah, the Gerald Ford. Right. So, you know, who knows what's going to happen there. But when you see troops amassing, it's never a good sign for the geopoliticals.
14:34 I mean, that's a whole show in itself with the military action against civilian... Jeff, we've talked about this before, civilian... Narco-terrorists. Yeah. That's a term that we've applied to this. Perhaps, we think, right? If, you know, unproven, right? But, presumably... You have to label it something if you're going to kill it. You know what I mean? So, like, but the whole, like, is this lawful? You know, that affects, and then this idea that we're going to amass military might in a region with a country we're not at war with.
15:24 Are we proactively going to invade or strike? Like, how are we that we don't have any kind of military, any declaration of war? Yeah. Actions do speak louder than words. The words indicated by the administration is no. That's no, we're not. But we're certainly flexing our military muscle in the region. And, you know, that can be appropriate as a tactic sometimes. Yeah, some kind of tactic. It can be. However, you know... It can also be a target and also... Well, that's where I'm going. At certain times in our history, us flexing our muscles has resulted in a response that should be expected.
16:12 I mean, if you're flexing your muscles, somebody might punch in the nose. And then the response leads to a response and... Escalation. That's right. Yeah. You know, history is full of those things. So to your point, Russ, and then there's Venezuela, right? I mean, so who knows what the next thing is? Right. So, yeah. Other areas of unknowns and uncertainty that I think that can drastically affect the news cycle and most likely the market is the Supreme Court case that was heard this week challenging the president's unilateral tariff moves, if you will.
16:56 In other words, does the president have the authority to start a tariff, institute a tariff on a foreign nation without congressional approval? If you're a student of history, you know it's been done before. If you're a student of the Constitution, you don't see that power in the Constitution. It is actually delegated to Congress. And, you know, the question is, and the justices, if you're listening to their questions, which were broad-based, broad-based meaning from the liberals and the conservatives on the court, is the tariff a tax?
17:37 If a tariff is a tax, then the president cannot do it, I think is what they're struggling with, because Congress is the entity that creates taxes and regulates taxes, not the president. And so the big what if, I think, the prognosticators are starting to go down this road is if the Supreme Court overturns these tariffs based upon the lack of president authority and the bills that he's, the legislation that he's using as an excuse to do it has never been done for this as well, if those taxes are revoked, those tariffs, I guess I showed my opinion, are revoked, what happens?
18:17 Do we have to pay back the money? And what does that mean to our debt and budget and, you know, all the things that are related to it? So I think that news. And I think the White House has been saying that if this is struck down, we'll just deem it a different, under a different power provided to the executive branch by the Congress. Well. And they'll just label it a different kind of. And then we're back to square one, it goes, start over. Yeah, you know, you can label a chicken a duck.
18:58 I don't disagree with you, Jeff. Don't get me wrong. But I think that's the positioning that I've heard come out of the White House. Well, if that that's not approved, we'll just we'll do it in a different form. Well, I said on a previous episode, this is months ago and probably when it first came out, this issue anyway, is why doesn't the Republican Congress just pass a law giving the president authority to tariff up to, you know, whatever they decide? That would have made it would have made this case moot if the president then had authority. They could have argued about between Liberation Day and the passage of the law. Oh, yes. But I'm surprised that the Republicans didn't do that.
19:41 And they could or and they could do it now or soon. They probably wouldn't get to pass the Senate. Another issue. You know, they could they could give the president authority. But, you know, a conservative court. Which this court is should be most interested in the four corners of the Constitution and limiting presidential authority, not expanding it. So I think that's where the case is going and what happens to the tariffs is open. I mean, the court could say, you know, effective today. You don't know, we didn't it wasn't clear that you didn't have the authority, blah, blah, blah.
20:24 Starting today, you do not have the authority. So no, no further. But that's still going to it's going to impact the market. Arguably, if that was the decision, it could affect the market positively. Yeah. Right. You know, so it's not exactly a black swan, but it is an unknown. I don't know if you listen to any of that, Jeff, yesterday, but I had it on in the background and a lot of it was over my head because they're really getting in the in the weeds of of the language of the rules and all that. So but it did sound like they were leaning against the president, at least from the questions that were being asked.
21:06 So I don't know. They'll be interesting to see how that plays out. It it did. But if you listen to listen to these cases for a long time, being a. Former Karen, I'm interested in this and constitutional issues sometimes you ask a question to maybe give your your side an opportunity to directly answer it for the other members of the court. But they did. If you just took them on the face value of the questions, it does not sound positive for the administration. Right. Yeah. You know, talking about market risk, one of the biggest things, you know, that I look at that I think about is, is this market too high?
21:46 Like it's not a general market risk, like for, you know, forever. But is this moment in time? Is this market are the value of the valuations of this stock market, maybe especially the side of it? Are we too frothy? Well, I think that is a recurring question that keeps coming up when we look at. Typically, we talk in terms of price to earnings ratios, they seem extended. And I think this is a challenge to address. Brian does endeavor to address that for our clientele.
22:29 He's made the case that one, the profitability prospects are very high and continue to grow at a rapid rate and can help to justify some of these numbers. I think that's one of the arguments people make. I think another he makes is this idea of a lot of these companies that multiples have recurring revenue. Subscription based revenue design, and that can justify higher multiple.
23:11 And the idea that the market as a whole, its composition is very different. The kinds of companies, ways in which revenues are drawn to profitability is different than it used to be. And it is more, maybe with greater predictability and greater worthy of a higher multiple in some respects. We didn't talk about interest rates, but Brian certainly would. Where interest rates are is a factor in all of this as well. What's the alternative that we're comparing things to is part of that equation as to what I might consider a willingness to pay for a stock.
24:01 So, a variety of inputs there. I think it remains a valid reality concern. Not to say that it's maybe as big a concern as we might think just by looking at the PE, but I think inevitably, no, we're always paying attention to market valuations. Certainly, today, I don't think you'd argue the market is cheap. And as an investor, you think about where you start the point from where you start.
24:41 If you're putting new money to work, it's different from, hey, I've been enjoying the ride. You might have more tolerance as someone who's put money in a long time ago and had a good run. And with that, you give up some of the gains when it comes back eventually. Whereas if you're putting new money to work and you're buying in and then there's disruptions, it's a little more of a painful process. It could be a longer wait to get to the other side. Volatility is inevitable. And I think as an investor, we have to have that mindset that that's why we get better returns, we get greater compensation, because we take more tolerance for enduring bumps in the road, the ups and downs.
25:43 And in consideration for that, we get better return. I agree with everything you said. And I generally agree with Brian's comments on this during our recent webinar that we had, which people can check out on YouTube.
26:30 We have a version for non-clients on our webinar if they'd like to check that out. I'll throw the link in the show notes if people want to review that. With that in mind, maybe for next week, what we'll do is we'll have Brian come on and talk a little bit about this issue and others to really elaborate on the notion of where are we in the market and how do we deal with it as a firm and our strategies and our team and our clients' portfolios that we manage with discretion. We pay attention to a lot of these risks, and it doesn't mean that we're not positioning with these in mind.
27:15 It's a very difficult scenario right now. On the one hand, you've got good things happening. On the other hand, we talk about some of the challenges that are stressing the markets. So how do you position? And Brian's taken a lot of effort in trying to position us both for enjoying some of the benefit while mitigating risk and having to do that with the winners, this sort of bifurcated possibility. We're making really broad comments about general views. This is a super individual analysis that we do for our clients.
27:56 This is a different conversation depending on your time horizon. If you're in retirement and you're using some of these invested funds in the near future, this could be an opportunity to take some risk off and build your liquidity bucket so you have the cash in the event of a market downturn. Rebalance to your intended allocation. Maybe that's changed over time. When markets are relatively high, it's a good time to think about, do I want to take some money for next year's spending? Do I want to refill my buckets? Do I want to reallocate? These kind of things.
28:37 And if you're on the other end of the spectrum, if you're Russ over here, in your accumulation phase and you are investing in your 401k or maybe adding some money to a brokerage account, the old adage, John Bogles, is it's time in the market and not timing the market. You just want to keep dollar cost averaging. You just want to keep contributing. You don't want to jump in and out because you're not going to do it at the right time. Nobody does that successfully long term. Unless there's market disruptions, who cares at that stage because you're buying. I remember rooting for them. And you're getting good deals when that happens.
29:19 So today's stocks at yesterday's prices, that kind of thing. So for the younger investor, just ignore it. Right. Right. Yep. Bye bye bye. So, you know, this is a good example where, you know, a financial advisor, a trusted financial advisor that you work with, if you have these concerns, you talk to him or her about it because the issues that you noted, Chris, about liquidity and maybe you want to reduce your risk. You know, you can talk that out without making an emotional decision. Most of the decisions that people make when the market's up or down, you know, to the extremes of the wrong decisions.
30:07 I mean, it's just the data on this is so clear that when the market's up, so many people say, get me some of that. And when the market's down, they say, get me out. And that, you know, might feel like an emotional survival technique. But it's, you know, greed and fear shouldn't drive your decisions. And that's where an advisor can really, you know, earn their keep by helping you walk through those and going through and having a financial plan that's written that you review and that helps you make these larger decisions without making a greed or fear decision. Well said. I think when you look at where we're at with markets, again, S&P 500s are up around 15% year to date.
31:01 And then, you know, when you look at longer term numbers, they're extended in the sense of we're at rates of return that are higher than we would expect long term. You know, if you say, oh, looking back, you know, three or five years or something, your performance from the market is looking more appealing than it probably will forever. You know what I mean? Though, the long term returns from markets tend to be a little lower than what we're currently at for these rates of return, annualized rates of return.
31:44 So that doesn't mean that there's necessarily a return to be the mean or whatever they were reverting to the mean. But I do think it is probably realistic to think of as long term averages are somewhere around 10% from stocks, we're averaging around 15 or whatever it might be. You know, you might expect that there's going to be some point. That's rational. Yep. I think people are so used to over the last three years, I mean, us included, I guess, and seeing the market go up and there are these little blips where there's like the liberation day or, you know, even COVID could be a big picture seen as a bit of a blip.
32:30 The way the market bounced back and it's pretty much been a straight line up when you look at the chart, other than these minor one or two month periods since, you know, I guess after 2022. So we're used to these double digit returns. And I remember at the beginning of the year, we were looking at valuations and we were like, you know, looks pretty expensive. But, you know, if you were invested, you would have missed out on these, again, double digit returns, which were unlikely for three years in a row. But here we are, you know, there's still some time left in the year, but it just goes to show that trying to time these things and trying to make these decisions, you know, thinking you have some foresight, it's not a winning game now.
33:22 You can't help but make parallels to the late 90s, though, at times because of these big return years, you know, you start to recollect some of that experience. Yep. And we do. It was the late 90s, the last time there were three consecutive years of double digit returns. So that was the leap to the early 2000s. Yeah, but even that, I mean, people in that period of time, there were long periods of really good returns. And yes, you had 1998 Asian contagion or whatever all the time.
34:08 There were disruptions within it, but there was a long period of time with extended favorable returns. And we could be in a period like that, where we have prolonged, you know, with this AI impact, the benefit of potential enhancement in productivity and profitability, that it could be consequential. You just have to be careful it doesn't get away from you as an investor that you're not so enamored of the returns that you are not attuned to the risks and not positioning in a way that your portfolio is ignoring the risks.
34:56 You know, you think in terms of that period when there were even the value funds being gone heavily toward growth, you know, there was this discipline in the way things were structured. And so I think it's a reminder to learn from those lessons. One, you know, be vigilant that you do have to be mindful of making some liquidity, not overstating your risk tolerance in an effort to capture favorable returns.
35:36 And being disciplined in the way you position your portfolio without going too far in one direction or another to be seeing the opportunity while at the same time you could be overstating risk. It's a challenging thing to do. So, well, that'll be a good thing for us to talk about again more in the future week. Jeff, were there other aspects that you're thinking of with the market risk or do we cover a lot of today's market risks that people are mindful of? Well, I think we could do another hour on different market risks, you know, inflation, interest rates and so forth.
36:18 The job market and politics as a whole separate one. But I think we covered the ones that are on our minds right now from the government shutdown to the impacts of that, you know, downstream a bit and world events and so forth. I think we've covered enough risks for today. So I guess my takeaway for our listeners is there's always risks to be monitored. They can be on this macro level, what's happening in the world, what's happening in the economy, what's happening in the markets broadly. It can be on an investment specific level, what's happening with a particular company I own.
37:01 Sometimes risks relate to things outside of your portfolio that relate to your own life and your potential needs. All of these variables are things that you may benefit from help in considering how do I prepare, how do I structure my portfolio, it should always be done in the context of the financial plan. And that financial plan helps you to prepare for the unforeseen with stress and the like. And if you don't have that happening with your current advisor or doing it on your own, and you might benefit from a little bit of help, either simplifying your portfolio, paying attention to tax strategies, all of the variables that we tend to.
37:49 We are this group here, we take for granted because it's things we talk about with people all the time. But if you're finding some of these concerns resonate, it might be a good time to have a conversation and see if a second set of models can be a resource for you, help you navigate how to deal with these. So with that, we leave that door open and offered to our listeners. Certainly reach out to us. We can be out to you until next time. Keep striving for something. Thank you for listening to something more with Chris Boyd. Call us for help, whether it's for financial planning or portfolio management, insurance concerns, or those quality of life issues that make the money matters matter.
38:34 Whatever's on your mind. Visit us at somethingmorewithchrisboyd.com or call us toll free at 866-771-8901. Or send us your questions to amr-info at wealthenhancement.com. You're listening to something more with Chris Boyd Financial Talk Show. Wealth Enhancement Advisory Services and Jay Christopher Boyd provide investment advice on an individual basis to clients only. Proper advice depends on a complete analysis of all facts and circumstances. The information given on this program is general financial comments and cannot be relied upon as pertaining to your specific situation. Wealth Enhancement Group cannot guarantee that using the information from this show will generate profits or ensure freedom from loss. Listeners should consult their own financial advisors or conduct their own due diligence before making any financial decisions.
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Castro
RSS Feed