Concentrated Stock & Capital Gains: Strategies to Manage Risk and Taxes
In this episode of Something More with Chris Boyd, Jeff Perry, and Russ Ball join Chris
to tackle the challenges of concentrated stock positions and embedded capital gains.
Whether it is legacy shares, inherited assets, or long-held business equity, these situations
can create significant tax and portfolio risk. The team explores smart strategies to manage
exposure, reduce volatility, and navigate tax implications without necessarily selling.
This episode is a must-listen for investors facing concentrated positions or advisors
helping clients preserve wealth while minimizing tax burdens.
For more information or to reach TEAM AMR, click the following link:
https://www.wealthenhancement.com/s/advisor-teams/amr
#CapitalGains #ConcentratedStock #TaxPlanning #InvestmentStrategy #PortfolioRisk
#WealthManagement #FinancialPlanning #EstateStrategy #OptionsHedging
#AssetAllocation
0:00 Welcome to Something More with Chris Boyd. Chris Boyd is a Certified Financial Planner Practitioner and Senior Vice President and Financial Advisor at Wealth Enhancement Group, one of the nation's largest registered investment advisors. We call it Something More because we'd like to talk not only about those important dollar and cents issues, but also the quality of life issues that make the money matters matter. Here he is, your fulfillment facilitator, your partner in prosperity, advising clients on Cape Cod and across the country. Here's your host, Jay Christopher Boyd. Welcome to Something More with Chris Boyd. I'm here with Jeff Perry and Russ Ball. We are all of the AMR team at Wealth Enhancement and glad to have you with us.
0:42 Today, we are talking about concentrated stock or actually, I think we could even extend this to circumstances where you have embedded capital gains, high capital gains concerns, and how do you navigate those? And what are some techniques that we can try to help you think about that? We tend to see this often when people have a long-term legacy position in a stock. Maybe they inherited it and have had it for years. Maybe they worked in an industry and had a stock in that instance. It could be, and in other instances, we've even seen like real estate or other types of assets that have a lot of embedded, a business or whatever, they have a lot of embedded capital gain.
1:32 And so how do you navigate trying to reduce that capital gains exposure or limit the risks when you have a concentrated stock? So there's different types of approaches and different ways we can navigate that. So let's talk about these a little bit. I was thinking, Russ, we've seemed like we keep running into this recently. What are some of the techniques that come to mind? Yeah. Well, I think when people start off with either concentrated in one position, like you said, or just legacy stocks that have been held over a long period of time since the 90s or whatever, the question is, what do you do?
2:20 How do you manage around that? And I think that's probably the most conservative option. We've been talking about concentrated stock recently. The most conservative option would be to manage what you can around those positions. But I don't want to sell them. I don't want to pay taxes. Yeah, that's a great point. So if I don't want to sell this position, well, first off, it's important to recognize, depending on the amount of scale, like how much we're in a particular position, this can add a magnitude of risk. So we generally think in terms of guidance for people to think around 5% of your investment portfolio in any one name, you get beyond that, you're starting to get to a point where you have more risk.
3:09 Even if it's maybe 10%, it might depend on the stock, the kind of company it is, but how diversified within the company. You might have multiple companies, different areas of business within it. Berkshire Hathaway. Berkshire Hathaway is a good example. Procter & Gamble, something like that. It's many companies all in one stock. So that kind of thing, that's a good example. But even so, we typically would say if it's getting beyond that 5% range, we're getting extra magnitude of risk built into the portfolio. And so that's where we start to get nervous. So the one way we can try to manage the risk is by looking at the asset allocation.
3:53 What's our overall allocation? And if we can, maybe there's places that we can reduce our overall exposure to risk, volatility, stock in this case. So we have had occasion where we talked about asset location. If we make those changes in our taxable accounts, well, there might be some tax consequences. But if we have non-taxable accounts or tax deferred, let's say, IRAs, 401ks, certainly Roth IRA too, but we tend to like to keep that for growth if we can.
4:34 But these might be places where we could make a change, or if you had annuity assets. These might be places where you could rearrange the allocation of what kind of investments you own without a tax consequence. And you might be able to scale up the lower risk investments as a starting point without any tax consequence. So that's maybe step one. That's what you're driving at? Yeah, exactly. To take a look at everything else. And if you're, for whatever reason, locked into that position, either you have a lot of conviction, you're extremely attached to that position because that does happen.
5:15 It's not always the best. That's probably not what we would prefer to have a sentimental attachment to specific positions, but it does happen. And I think another piece is, yes, on the asset allocation side to try to reduce risk in other areas, but also reducing risk away from that specific sector. So if it's a tech stock that this individual might have or whatever it may be, you can- Well, we have an example of an older gentleman who has telecom stocks. They've had- Acquired them through a ESOP, an employee.
5:55 Or inherited or whatever. Either way, they got them. I was talking with a client recently where they went through the breakup and now come back together. They've been round trip on their telecom stocks. So the basis on these is nil. And on the one hand, you'd say, well, maybe I'd rather just hold onto it until I pass away because there's a step up in basis for my heirs. But there's also this, we're missing out on opportunity because the performance of these stocks isn't as good.
6:38 The dividend is nice, but the overall performance has been subpar. So maybe how old I am is part of this equation, right? We have a case where we're dealing with a family who has the owner is in his 90s, I want to say, and some legacy stocks. Well, I get why. So how do we, in that case, maybe it's more about how do we mitigate risk? In some cases, it might be, where can we make some changes? There might be some low hanging fruit. Some of these stocks may actually be worth less than what they have as basis.
7:24 And there can be opportunities to do some offsetting of capital gains with capital losses. But for example, if you owned, just as an example, if you own GE in the 90s or the early 2000s, and it's seen drastic changes in the way GE is structured and priced and so forth, you might actually have a capital loss in your mix to draw from. And that could work against something else that you have as a big long-term capital gain, as an example. So in any case, but if we've got instances where we might have something we would like to try to hold on to because we'd rather have the step up in basis, what's a way we might be able to navigate the risks?
8:20 Perhaps an option strategy could be a consideration. You want to talk about that, Russ? Yeah. So especially if you have one stock or a concentrated group of stocks, but really it works best, I think, if we're talking about one specific stock. A single position that's concentrated. Yep. If you say, this stock has done really well, I'm worried about how it's going to affect my overall portfolio if that stock plummets tomorrow. Because I've got such a large concentration in this one company. Yeah. So yeah. Go ahead. Yeah. Just that there are ways we can use an option strategy to hedge against that downside risk.
9:04 So you'd basically be buying a put and I'll let you... Yeah. So I'll take on this. So I think we don't need to get too into the weeds on this. I think most people would say, options? I don't want to have risk. I'm trying to reduce my risk. And options sounds like, because of what we hear from people, oftentimes options are used for leverage to give me enhanced risk, but to try to get more juice in a portfolio. That's not what we're talking about here. Well, one of the ways options can be used is to mitigate downside risk. Think like an insurance policy. I can pay a premium, buy an insurance policy to mitigate my downside.
9:50 And essentially, I might still have some downside, but I might be able to say, I want to put a floor on that downside. And usually when we do these approaches, so we're buying, we're paying a premium for that to protect that downside, but we might also sell an option to cap our upside so that it will help to pay for this insurance. And when we use a team that does this exclusively, oftentimes they can manage this in a way where we can try to avoid having an actual transaction occur. They can get rid of the contracts, roll the contracts and just keep moving the expiration date further down the line to avoid any kind of experience where we have to sell the security that we really don't want to sell for a tax purpose.
10:47 So that's one possible way is this involved, but sophisticated way of mitigating risk through the use of options as a way to limit downside exposure. And it's important to recognize when you buy insurance, there's usually a premium involved. So there is some cost oftentimes when you're doing this. You can mitigate some of that cost and make it more manageable and not so painful in the process. But I think we probably overlooked the first and most obvious choice of when you have this issue.
11:30 If you've got concentrated stock, you don't really want to pay the tax. But in some cases, we've had clients and friends who've had a concentrated position, had a huge run up, felt great, made a lot of money, but I don't want to pay that tax. And they chose not to. Well, and the good news is the stock has changed in price and they don't have a capital gains tax anymore, but that's not always the good news. That's bad news too, that the price has changed.
12:11 So sometimes it's worth biting the bullet, just recognizing you don't own all the value of that stock. Uncle Sam's got a claim on some of the gain. And so many people put the primary decision as the tax consequence of whether or not to sell an investment. And that's a factor, but it's really not the most important factor. The most important factor from my perspective is what's the outlook for the stock? Is it in a growing industry? Are their earnings good? Is the company being managed right? Is it in the right sector? Where are we in the business cycle?
12:52 All these things that Brian and you do, Chris, when you're analyzing a stock, either fundamentally or technically, but that should be question one. I own this stock. Is the future of the stock positive? That's a whole different analysis than holding some old industrial company because you've got a large capital gain that's in a business that is questionable for the future. We had a conversation with someone who thinks the company is great that they have a concentrated position in, but they think it's kind of had a good run and maybe it's a little overpriced right now. What if you're someone else who says, well, it's not the stock I don't like. I think we're poised for a downturn with the markets or the economy.
13:36 We're in a position where the outlook isn't as good. Or even the sector, right? Or the sector, right? So those are all variables that make it more difficult to navigate. On the one hand, I want to say, one of the options is you could sell. It's painful. Nobody likes taxes, but on some level, historically, taxes are relatively inexpensive today. That's a good point too, right? It may not be a bad thing to consider. All right. So that's one option. And not an all or nothing proposition too. Absolutely right. All right. So that's one option. We have a gentleman who has capital gains from real estate that they're dealing with.
14:22 And we're trying to navigate that. Let's talk about the idea of how do we try to manage capital gains through the try to create a mechanism where we can generate intentionally, generate capital losses. So this is another possibility. You want to start and I'll jump in? Yeah. Well, I think it's important to remember that capital gains and losses are not just in your stock portfolio. They're also, like you said, if you're selling a business, if you're selling a home, capital gains- Like a rental property or like an investment property type of- Yeah.
15:02 I mean, or your own property. Yeah. I guess it's after a certain amount of gain. Right. Depending on the value, right? Yeah. So those gains, they're still capital gains when you sell a house and they could be offset by losses in your stock portfolio because those are capital losses. So one option is, it can get a little bit into the weeds to go into the details, but it's based on a direct indexing sort of approach. And direct indexing basically is you look at a portfolio like the S&P 500 and rather than buying a mutual fund or ETF that contains all of it in one security, you're saying, I'm going to break that up.
15:45 I'm going to buy a number, a hundreds sometimes of those stocks in the portfolio. Yeah. So it moves in a way that's similar to that index. But in the midst of that, with all these individual positions, some of them go down. And we could replace those positions that went down with something that's very similar. So we'll stay invested in a way that it still continues to look like the index, but I can capture all these little moves on the downside to benefit from that capital loss, that decline in value for a small piece of the mix and harvest that to help me manage gains that I have to deal with elsewhere.
16:38 And in some instances, we might even leverage that where we have a long short strategy paired with that, where we're going to put a little bit more exposure on top and below, where if we're buying long and selling short, and if the market goes up, well, one portion of that is going to make money, but another portion of that is going to lose money. The short portion would have losses. If we see the market go down, well, the long portion has losses, but the short portion will have made money.
17:18 So we're neutral to what happens in the market because we've got long and short, but invariably, some portion of that will give us an opportunity to harvest losses. And we can use that in a way to try to capture some tax benefit now and use that as a way to help to offset that gain. We might be dealing with that real estate, or in the case of the concentrated position, we might be able to sell some holdings to help mitigate that risk, that tax, and to diversify from the risk that we have in the concentrated stock.
18:04 And one additional benefit is that when you generate those losses, let's say you get into one of these strategies and the market starts going down right away, you start racking up losses, it's not going to feel great because you're kind of going along the ride with the market, but you're also generating losses that you can carry forward year after year, as long as you live, really. Yeah, we have someone who has this kind of a circumstance with a future sale of an appreciated asset. It's not today, but they know they're thinking of selling this appreciated asset and want to be prepared for the future gains.
18:49 So they're locking in losses to sort of capture those so that then they just stay. You get to deduct $3,000 a year, so they might diminish a little bit over time, but you've banked those losses so you can use them against future gains, and it's another date down the road. So that can also be, with some forethought, some time to prepare, you can be better situated for when you have that. So it's an unusual thought process. I think sometimes we talk about capturing losses and harvesting losses, and people think, why would you want to have losses?
19:29 You don't necessarily want to have losses. But in this case, we can intentionally set out to manipulate the structure of things so that we can gather those losses to help offset taxes. And that is another form of return. It's not what you make, it's what you keep. So this helps us to have what they call tax alpha. We're going to have some added benefit and have a better effective outcome because of trying to mitigate some of that tax burden. And it may be that we still have some tax burden down the road, but in the case of, say, the concentrated position or the instance of the real estate that we're trying to avoid a tax on, this gives us the opportunity to push that problem down the road a little bit.
20:24 And in the case of some of these, it gives us more opportunity for more diversification, which may be... That's what I was going to comment on, that you're doing that strategy in the context of a broad-based index situation. So you're, in essence, have that diversification, not only by company, but also by sector and so forth. So you're not trying to pick winners and losers. You're doing it in a context of what a lot of people like to do is invest in index. Yeah. And there's a certain efficiency there. But in our case, what we're really just trying to do is diminish risk. And that can give us a way to effectively accomplish that.
21:07 So there are other techniques that are even more involved and sophisticated that maybe go beyond the scope of a program like this. But I think it's important to just recognize that this is a challenge that people... It's not unique to have this difficulty of either a long-held stock position, even if it's inherited, maybe inherited from a parent or something. And this is very common. People have stuff, they just hold onto it and never change it. And then now, 20 years later or whatever it might be, you're faced with, oh, maybe I should think about my investments in a strategy that's appropriate for me.
21:54 What should I do? And there's all this embedded tax concern. So that's not unusual. It's not unusual for people to have stock maybe from an employer, maybe to have real estate that's appreciated, a business that's appreciated. And having the reality that we've got a gain that we're going to be faced with, how do we manage that gain and try to offset some of that gain through the use of a technique like this to help diminish capital gains exposure by capturing losses along the way or by mitigating the risk through the use of options as a way to navigate that.
22:46 Or just looking at your overall portfolio and looking at where there are places where we can do some changes without some tax burden to help manage risk. There's a variety of things to look at. It's best done in the context of a financial plan. Is that where you're going? Absolutely. No, I was just going to say that it's also not like you have to choose one solution and go with that. We try to take a look at it all within that financial plan context as well. But we look at the whole picture and we decide, all right, here's what we're going to do with this piece. Here's what we would do with this piece. And maybe some hedging, some tax loss harvesting, rather than it all being in one specific strategy.
23:29 I remember a couple of clients we've worked with years past where we had this issue, appreciated assets, but we also had the desire for income over a lifetime. And in some instances, some charitable intentions. Sometimes people prioritize charitable intent and other times people just prioritize mitigating, avoiding capital gains. We talk about a charitable remainder trust, also known as a capital gains avoidance trust. It's really more of a, it's not avoidance, but you're not getting hit with it all at once.
24:13 It's a graduate, you can push it off. But the idea of taking some position that's concentrated with a lot of capital gains in it, we've done this a number of times where people have donated that stock to this charitable intention eventually, but get a charitable deduction right up front. So some immediate tax benefit and the ability to then derive income. We can reposition in the trust that stock into something that's more diversified and more balanced and structure it where they can generate a cashflow from this for themselves, for themselves and a spouse.
24:59 We have one woman who did it with herself, her spouse, and her sibling. So as long as any one of them is alive and their assets remain in the trust that there's still presumably going to outlive them all, there's income stream provided to them. And there's different ways to structure a charitable remainder trust. One that's geared to try to maximize income to the family, the donors, the beneficiaries, but there's also some that are more regimented, but can have more growth so that there's more for the charitable intentions later on.
25:41 So depending on what we're trying to do, there's ways to structure that. There are other techniques as well that are state planning techniques. I think I mentioned one to you. I didn't even remember now what it was. Do you remember what my brother mentioned something to me just today? I'll look it up. And that may be something we want to look into for people as well in their estate planning, but a deferred sales trust is another technique he was talking about. So the estate planning can provide some interesting opportunities as well that we can try to collaborate with all these various ways of trying to manage how best to handle these appreciated assets.
26:27 And the time horizon involved is certainly relevant. It might be. The solution or the mitigation of these taxes may be a multi-year approach. Yeah, yeah, exactly. Good point. And so let's just kind of wind it down to say that this is all best done in the context of a financial plan. So we know how all the pieces fit together. We can think about estate planning considerations and charitable giving considerations. Think about some of these techniques we've just elaborated on and the context of the portfolio, how the rest of all those pieces fit together.
27:09 If you're faced with some of these kinds of issues, you're not alone. There's lots of people who have similar kind of challenges and a little bit of planning can go a long way and helping you to navigate that tax cost. Russ and I were just talking last night and saying, it seems like tax priorities, tax issues, it's more on people's minds today than ever before. How do I navigate and manage my expenses when it comes to tax costs as part of my investment strategies? It's probably more than ever on people's minds. There are some great resources and techniques.
27:52 And if you need help navigating how that works for you, give us a call, reach out. Don't hesitate to try to see if we can be a resource in helping you figure out what's the best path forward, not only for your portfolio, but for your overall life circumstances for your financial plan. So with that, thanks for being with us. And if any way we can be of help, reach out. Until next time, keep striving for something more.
28:45 AMR-info at wealthenhancement.com. You're listening to something more with Chris Boyd Financial Talk Show. Wealth Enhancement Advisory Services and Jay Christopher Boyd provide investment advice on an individual basis to clients only. Proper advice depends on a complete analysis of all facts and circumstances. The information given on this program is general financial comments and cannot be relied upon as pertaining to your specific situation. Wealth Enhancement Group cannot guarantee that using the information from this show will generate profits or ensure freedom from loss. Listeners should consult their own financial advisors or conduct their own due diligence before making any financial decisions.
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Castro
RSS Feed